but if you could just see the beauty / these things I could never describe / these pleasures of wayward distraction / this is my one lucky prize...
-”Isolation”, Joy Division.
I don’t exactly identify with Schulman’s New York, but I wish I did. The other narraratives seem to view New York as something great and spectacular that exists around them; something they do not exactly interact with so much as observe. Schulman views New York as exactly with it is, whatever that may be, accepting it and living with it, developing her own method of working within it.
In reality, I think I identified with Kazin’s view of New York, namely the following quote: “…I could look straight across to the skyscrapers of Manhattan, I saw New York as a foreign city.” It’s so easy to see New York as a foreign city. I’ve never seen anything like it. At the same time, it’s completely familiar. The trick is to not see it as a whole but to see it as a kind of puzzle. Seeing New York as a solitary mass makes it overwhelming.
Besides that, I liked the way White mentioned events and where they took place, not by giving the address of the event, but relating it in blocks to how far it happened from where he is/was currently located. It both lends to the myth of New York of this greatly eventful place as well as related to it in a human way; this is where things happen, beautiful things as well as not so attractive.
Didion’s New York seemed so distant, but at the same time understandable. I’ve also had days where I didn’t want to leave the comfort of my safe, secure bed to go out and see people and places I didn’t care for seeing. Abbey’s idea of New York seems to also include New Jersey and I don’t stand for any of that. New Jersey is not New York. New Jersey is a giant highway that leads me to New York. I’m not sure how I feel about Abbey’s passage.